We’ve got big fillings about Baloney’s Deli.
We’ve got big fillings about Baloney’s Deli.
Get bready folks because the deli gods have answered our prayers and unrelenting carbs cravings (which are one of the same) in the form of Baloney’s Deli.
Serving serious sub-stantial vibes, Baloney’s Deli, the saucy new spot serving up New York-Italian sando realness (with a side of Sopranos nostalgia), is making us melt. Opening earlier this year, this slick yet classy hideaway tucked behind the police station in Byron Bay ticks all the right boxes.
Helmed by George McFarlane – chef, world traveller, sandwich savant, and MBA holder (yes, he’s got business buns as well as sanga buns), Baloney’s is the ultimate tribute to deli culture. After slicing his way through top-tier kitchens like Pixie Italian and Mortadeli, George decided it was time to craft a space of his own and we’re so ‘grilled’ he did.
With an open kitchen that lets you chat to the chef (“hi George!”), a deck made for lingering long lunches, and big plans for future deli expansion, this place is built for connection between food, people, and a mutual love of all things sliced, pickled, and pressed.
The interiors, designed by Sam Mathews of Happy Hour Fitout fame (of You Beauty, Ciao Mate, and The Eltham Hotel fame), are an absolute snack. Think rich dark wood, black-and-white checkered floors, espresso-toned tiles with a crema pinstripe (yes, even the benches are getting their caffeine fix), and the pièce de resistance – a $600 church pew that sets the holy tone for your sandwich salvation.
Add in a cheeky nod to The Sopranos’ Satriale’s Pork Store, and you’ve got a deli that feels as authentic as Nonna’s meatballs, with just the right amount of mob boss energy.
But it’s not all style and no substance – Baloney’s is bringing the goods and crust us, anyway you slice it, the menu is deli-icious. Let’s start with the signature lunch eats, like the ‘Who’s Reuben’, with pastrami, sauerkraut, cheese, Baloney’s dressing, pickles and mustard on rye, or the Mortadelli Papi, loaded with mortadella, stracciatella, guindillas, and green olives on focaccia.
If you’re more of a breakfast buff, let’s cut to the cheese – Boloney’s is where it’s at. Think pastries like croissants, cannoli, pain au chocolate, and cinnamon scrolls. Or for a heartier feed, sink your chompers into the Four Cheese with mozzarella, gruyère, cheddar and comté and why not add mortadella and sundried tomatoes because you can.
Pair your eats with a Coffee Supreme’s Boxer blend for that trad bold, punchy Italiano flavour and speaking of, don’t even get us started on the $2 standing espresso bar—perfect for pretending you’re in a back alley in Naples rather than just off the main drag in Byron.
And, on Easter Saturday, you can wash your meal down with something stronger when the Bar-loney’s concept kicks off. This meatball sub and wine collab with @Sarni.Bne is testing the waters for a more permanent offering, which is precisely our bread and butter.
So if you’re craving a little New York hustle with your Italian bustle, make your way to Baloney’s Deli and prepare to fall head over heels in loaf.
Where: 10-12 Shirley Street, Byron Bay
When: 8am – 2.30pm Tuesday to Sunday. Closed Monday
Words by Bianca Trathen.